FHL Attribute Primer: what the ratings actually do
A plain-language guide to how player ratings affect games in FHLSIM (build 444). It is based on formulas recovered from the game engine and checked against real simulated games, not on the manual's descriptions alone.
How much to trust each statement
| Tag | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Confirmed | The exact formula was recovered and matched the running game with zero mismatches. |
| Inferred | The numbers are exact, but the hockey meaning is our interpretation. |
| Not found | We have not located this attribute in the game engine yet. Only the manual's description is available. |
Ratings are shown on the 0-99 scale. Inside the engine they are divided by 10. That detail does not change anything for you.
Part 1: How a game is simulated
The clock
A game is three 20-minute periods. The sim moves forward in 5-second steps, 240 steps per period. Each side has five skaters and a goalie on the ice.
Where the puck is
At any moment one team has the puck, and play is in one of three places: team A's end, neutral ice, or team B's end. Each step, the sim decides what happens next.
flowchart LR
A[Team has puck] --> B{Keep it, or lose it?}
B -- lose --> A2[Other team has puck]
B -- keep --> C{Advance a zone?}
C -- yes --> D{Enter their zone cleanly?}
D -- offside / failed entry --> F[Faceoff in neutral zone]
D -- clean entry --> E{Take a shot?}
E -- yes --> G[Shot: goal, save, or rebound]
G -- saved --> H[Faceoff, or puck changes hands]
C -- rare --> X[High-quality chance, such as a breakaway]
X --> GHits and fatigue run alongside this flow. We have confirmed each individual piece below, but not the exact order in which every step is called within the 5-second tick.
The core idea: strength contests
Almost every decision is a weighted coin flip. The sim adds up the relevant ratings for each side, then draws a random number. Your chance equals your share of the total. If Side A scores 600 and Side B scores 400, A wins about 60%.
- Stars count disproportionately. Ratings are raised to a power, usually between 1.5 and 2.9. Going from 80 to 90 adds much more than going from 60 to 70. Elite players in the right category are worth more than a few average ones.
- Condition scales everything. A player at 80% condition contributes 80% of his rating-based strength.
- Rare bad moments. For each player in each calculation, there is a baseline 1-in-20 chance of a "lapse" where his ratings don't count. The chance rises to 1-in-10 or 1-in-5 in some situations (see Part 3).
Special teams (Inferred)
The sim tracks how many men each team has serving penalties and caps the gap at two. That gap shifts almost every strength calculation, adjusts the lapse chance, and selects different line combinations (power play and penalty kill units).
Fatigue and line changes (Confirmed)
- A skater on the ice loses condition every 5 seconds. A skater on the bench recovers it.
- When the on-ice line's average condition falls below 90, the sim changes lines. It does not do this automatically while that team is pinned in its own end.
- Being hit also costs condition (see IT, ST and SK below).
- At even strength the sim rotates through a fixed cycle of line codes. When there is a man advantage or disadvantage it picks the special-teams lines.
Comeback and balance effects (Confirmed)
- Shot pace is self-correcting. The sim aims for about 29 shots per team per game with the current league setting. A team that falls behind that pace gets more shot chances, and a team ahead of it gets fewer.
- Scoreless teams get a boost. A team with 0 goals gets +10 attack in the 1st period, +20 in the 2nd and +30 in the 3rd.
- Runaway scoring is dampened. A team with 6 or more goals loses 10 attack for each goal above 5.
- League settings matter. The scoring setting adds or subtracts 10 attack per notch. The shot-frequency setting moves the target pace. The "frequent hits" option adds 5 percentage points to every hit chance.
What the sim does not appear to use (so far)
Home-ice advantage, coach ratings, tactics, and the overall (OV) rating. OV is a summary figure for humans. Its weights differ a lot from what the game engine uses, so a high OV does not guarantee a high impact. This list may shrink as the investigation continues.
Part 2: What each attribute does
IT: Intensity
Hits (Confirmed). The player who delivers a hit is chosen from the defending team's skaters, weighted by IT. The hitter's own IT sets the chance:
| IT | Chance per opportunity |
|---|---|
| 0-40 | 5% |
| 41-60 | 10% |
| 61-70 | 15% |
| 71-80 | 20% |
| 81-90 | 25% |
| 91+ | 30% |
- Puck battles, shot creation, shot suppression (Confirmed). IT feeds all of these. It is strongest in suppressing shots (power 1.8) and in faceoffs (1.7).
- Defensemen's on-ice defense (Confirmed). IT is part of the bonus a pair of defensemen gives their goalie.
- Goalie (Confirmed). IT is alertness. It is one of the biggest parts of save strength, and on high-quality chances the goalie gets a 50% strength boost if an alertness check succeeds. Success is about 57% at IT 50, 80% at IT 80, and 98% at IT 99.
- Fighting (Inferred). The manual says low discipline combined with IT leads to fights. IT appears in the same engine routines as DI.
SP: Speed
- Steals, advancing the puck, shot creation, shot suppression (Confirmed). A modest, broad contribution to every contest.
- Faceoffs (Confirmed). The center's SP counts.
- Scoring chances (Confirmed). A forward's SP adds directly to his shot's attack strength.
- Goalie (Confirmed). SP is the single most powerful goalie rating for save strength (power 2.92). Going from 70 to 90 SP adds about 23% to base strength.
ST: Strength
- Winning puck battles (Confirmed). ST helps the carrier keep the puck, a defender take it away, and a line advance. It is also part of shot creation and suppression.
- Taking hits (Confirmed). The player who gets hit is chosen in proportion to ST, so bigger players absorb more hits and tire faster.
- Defensemen's on-ice defense (Confirmed).
- Goalie (Confirmed). ST counts for saves (power 2.19), worth roughly 4% of base strength going from 70 to 90.
EN: Endurance (Confirmed for fatigue)
EN controls how fast a player tires on the ice and recovers on the bench.
| EN | Condition lost per minute on ice (baseline) | Recovered per minute on bench |
|---|---|---|
| 90 | about 4 | about 13.5 |
| 50 | about 8 | about 7.5 |
| 30 | about 10 | about 4.5 |
Each shift ends when the line's average condition falls below 90, so a high-EN line stays out longer and comes back stronger. The loss figures are before an opponent-side factor (fieldFD6) that we have not named yet. Because condition scales strength, EN matters most for players who log heavy minutes.
DU: Durability (Not found)
No use of DU has been found in the game-simulation code yet. The game does produce injuries ("sidelined for...") and returns from injury. The manual says DU is directly proportional to how often a player comes out of a game unhurt. Treat that as the working assumption.
DI: Discipline (Partly found)
DI appears in engine routines for penalties, fights ("beats up", "fight to a draw"), ejections and suspensions. In the fight routine, both players' DI must be below a cutoff, plus other checks, before a fight can happen. The manual says low DI means more penalties and more fights when combined with IT. The exact penalty formula has not been recovered.
SK: Skating
- Getting past the blue line (Confirmed). Forward SK is the biggest ingredient in advancing the puck (power 1.8). On zone entry, the sim adds SK + PC for the non-defense skaters. Forwards averaging 80 SK and 80 PC fail about 20% of entries; at 90 and 90, about 10%.
- Breakaway-style chances (Confirmed). On a rare high-quality chance, a forward's SK is added to his weight for being the shooter.
- Taking hits (Confirmed). A hit costs the receiver 11 minus the tens digit of his SK in condition points: 2 at SK 90+, 3 in the 80s, 4 in the 70s, 5 in the 60s, up to 11 below SK 10.
- Defending (Confirmed). A small, linear contribution to suppressing shots.
- Goalie (Confirmed). Surprisingly small for saves, about 0.4% of base strength from 70 to 90. SK plus PA also gives a modest chance, roughly SK+PA percent, to smother a scramble and force play back to neutral ice.
PA: Passing
- Moving the puck (Confirmed). PA is a major part of keeping possession (power 1.7) and advancing play. Non-defensemen also get a flat bonus of 2 x PA for advancing.
- Creating shots (Confirmed). PA is part of attack strength.
- Assists and goal chances (Confirmed). On about 95% of ordinary shots a teammate is chosen as passer, favoring high PA and PC. The passer's PA raises the shot's chance of becoming a goal. Assist selection is roughly PA^3.9 + PC^2.1. Defensemen are weighted at half for the first assist.
- Goalie (Confirmed). After a save,
2 x PA + PChelps decide whether play stops for a faceoff or keeps moving. A goalie can occasionally record an assist.
PC: Puck Control
- Keeping the puck, advancing, creating shots (Confirmed). Counted in all three.
- Faceoffs (Confirmed). PC is the center's biggest faceoff ingredient, along with DF (both power 1.9).
- Entering the zone (Confirmed). PC is half of the SK+PC entry test above.
- Assists (Confirmed). See PA.
- Goalie (Confirmed). PC heavily affects save strength (power 2.66), adding about 12% of base strength from 70 to 90, and rebound control. Loose-puck chance is about 58% at PC 70 and 37% at PC 90. Even then, a rebound shot follows only about one time in five, depending on the defensemen.
DF: Defense
- Suppressing shots (Confirmed). DF has the strongest power in the game (2.1) inside the defending-unit strength. Defensemen also get an extra DF bonus.
- Winning the puck back (Confirmed). DF is the biggest ingredient in stealing the puck.
- Faceoffs (Confirmed). See PC.
- Defensemen protect their goalie (Confirmed). Each defenseman adds
35 + IT^1.7 + ST^1.5 + DF^1.7to a running total, which is halved and added to goalie strength. That also makes rebounds less likely. - Advancing the puck (Confirmed). A non-defenseman's DF adds a little to his line's ability to push forward.
SC: Scoring
SC does not affect how many shots a team gets. Shot volume comes from IT, SP, ST, PA and PC. SC affects the shot once it is taken:
- Who shoots (Confirmed). Shooters are picked by weight, starting from 3 x SC. Defensemen are slightly reduced. Weights get a bonus from SC squared for a team with a man advantage (Inferred), so top scorers take more power-play shots.
- Goal chance (Confirmed). SC is the biggest single skater factor in goal chance (power 2.4). Forwards also add SC and SP directly. Defensemen's attack is divided by 2.4 and gets no such bonus.
EX: Experience (Partly found)
EX shows up only in rare "lapse" moments:
- A shooter whose lapse triggers has attack multiplied by
0.6 x EX / 10, so EX 90 keeps 54% and EX 30 keeps 18%. - The goalie formula also uses EX in the same rare situation.
We have not found where the "Experience & Leadership" league option is read.
LD: Leadership (Not found)
No use of LD has been found in the engine. The manual says leaders make the whole team more consistent from game to game and shift to shift. That is consistent with the lapse mechanism, but there is no evidence for it yet.
Part 3: Situations that change how often lapses happen
Each lapse check starts at a 1-in-20 chance. The limit is halved once for each condition that applies:
- A man advantage or disadvantage is in play.
- An internal game flag we have not identified is set.
- The opposing team has no goals and it is the 3rd period.
- The team has more than double the opponent's shots.
The limit steps down 20, 10, 5, 2, 1. Only the first three steps (5%, 10%, 20%) were seen in the captured games.
Part 4: Cheat sheet
| If you want... | Look at... |
|---|---|
| A great goalie | SP first, then PC and IT, then ST. SK barely matters for saves. |
| Fewer shots against | DF (strongest power), IT, ST, and a defense corps with high DF. |
| More shots for | IT, SP, ST, PA and PC across all five skaters. SC is not on this list. |
| Goals from the shots you take | SC and SP on your shooters, PA on your passers. |
| Faceoff wins | Center's IT, SP, PC and DF. PC and DF count most. |
| Clean zone entries | SK and PC of your forwards. |
| Lots of assists | PA and PC. |
| Fewer rebounds against | Goalie PC, plus strong defensemen on the ice. |
| Players who last | EN, and a line that can stay out of its own end. |
| Fewer fights and penalties | High DI (manual). Exact effect not yet recovered. |
Part 5: Still to be explored
- DU, LD and the Experience & Leadership option.
- The exact formulas for penalties, fights, ejections and injuries.
- What the unidentified game flags and the opposing-team fatigue factor mean.
- Exactly how special teams, shift changes, coaches and home ice fit in.
Technical references
- STATUS.md: current progress
- analysis/possession-model.md: puck possession, faceoffs and zone entry
- analysis/shot-attempt-model.md: shot attempts
- analysis/shot-model.md: shooters, goals, saves, rebounds and assists
- analysis/hit-model.md: hits
- analysis/maintenance-model.md: fatigue and line changes
- analysis/ov-reference.md: OV formulas